Casey Key is a wonderfully secluded barrier Island located just 15 miles south of Sarasota. Its charm lies in its uniqueness- it is comprised almost solely of single-family residences. Due to zoning regulations, no new commercial properties may be established on the island. As a result, an enclave of the finest Sarasota real estate sits on this quiet but majestic island. Casey Key is eight miles long, and is accessible via two bridges. With just over 400 homes on the island, it feels like it is miles away from the traffic jams of Sarasota- making those who call it home proud. Many of the home sites on Casey offer the unique advantage of being Gulf-to-Bay, that is, being surrounded on both sides by water. For inspiration on your next new beach home, have a look at the new listings below.
(98)
Virtual Tour
(60)
Virtual Tour
(33)
Virtual Tour
(80)
Virtual Tour
(54)
Virtual Tour
(92)
Virtual Tour
(60)
Virtual Tour
(99)
Open House:
Apr 19, 2025, 1:00 PM - 4:00 PM
Virtual Tour
Virtual Tour
(47)
(91)
Virtual Tour
Virtual Tour
(55)
Virtual Tour
(64)
Virtual Tour
(41)
Virtual Tour
(53)
Virtual Tour
(98)
Virtual Tour
(91)
Virtual Tour
(45)
Virtual Tour
(96)
Virtual Tour
(61)
Virtual Tour
(57)
Virtual Tour
(91)
Virtual Tour
(83)
Listing No.
TB8352474
Listing No.
A4643654
Listing No.
A4628430
Listing No.
N6137575
Listing No.
A4632022
Listing No.
N6137722
Listing No.
A4642022
Listing No.
A4634191
Open House:
Apr 19, 2025, 1:00 PM - 4:00 PM
Listing No.
A4636387
Listing No.
A4635826
Listing No.
A4643566
Listing No.
A4643096
Listing No.
A4630341
Listing No.
N6137711
Listing No.
A4583445
Listing No.
N6119928
Listing No.
A4648103
Listing No.
A4648844
Listing No.
N6137556
Listing No.
N6134765
Listing No.
A4636300
Listing No.
A4634966
Listing No.
N6134950
(98)
$16,000,000
5 5 Beds
6 | 3 6 | 3 Baths
8,468 Sqft 8,468 Sqft
TB8352474 Listing No. TB8352474
House Property Type: House
(98)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(60)
$11,750,000
5 5 Beds
6 | 2 6 | 2 Baths
8,050 Sqft 8,050 Sqft
A4643654 Listing No. A4643654
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(60)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(33)
$10,100,000
5 5 Beds
5 | 1 5 | 1 Baths
5,414 Sqft 5,414 Sqft
A4628430 Listing No. A4628430
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(33)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(80)
$8,975,000
5 5 Beds
6 6 Baths
6,891 Sqft 6,891 Sqft
N6137575 Listing No. N6137575
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(80)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(54)
$8,450,000
5 5 Beds
6 | 1 6 | 1 Baths
6,596 Sqft 6,596 Sqft
A4632022 Listing No. A4632022
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(54)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(92)
$8,400,000
5 5 Beds
5 | 1 5 | 1 Baths
5,249 Sqft 5,249 Sqft
N6137722 Listing No. N6137722
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(92)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(60)
$7,500,000
5 5 Beds
8 | 1 8 | 1 Baths
7,616 Sqft 7,616 Sqft
A4642022 Listing No. A4642022
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(60)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(99)
$6,995,000
4 4 Beds
5 | 1 5 | 1 Baths
3,906 Sqft 3,906 Sqft
A4634191 Listing No. A4634191
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(99)
Open House: Apr 19, 2025, 1:00 PM - 4:00 PM
VIRTUAL TOUR
$6,950,000
4 4 Beds
5 | 1 5 | 1 Baths
5,397 Sqft 5,397 Sqft
A4636387 Listing No. A4636387
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
VIRTUAL TOUR
(47)
$6,450,000
4 4 Beds
4 | 1 4 | 1 Baths
5,714 Sqft 5,714 Sqft
A4635826 Listing No. A4635826
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(47)
(91)
$6,445,000
4 4 Beds
4 | 2 4 | 2 Baths
6,335 Sqft 6,335 Sqft
A4643566 Listing No. A4643566
House Property Type: House
(91)
VIRTUAL TOUR
$5,250,000
6 6 Beds
4 | 1 4 | 1 Baths
3,983 Sqft 3,983 Sqft
A4643096 Listing No. A4643096
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
VIRTUAL TOUR
(55)
$4,800,000
4 4 Beds
4 | 1 4 | 1 Baths
3,310 Sqft 3,310 Sqft
A4630341 Listing No. A4630341
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(55)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(64)
$4,750,000
3 3 Beds
3 3 Baths
2,582 Sqft 2,582 Sqft
N6137711 Listing No. N6137711
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(64)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(41)
$4,500,000
3 3 Beds
2 2 Baths
1,876 Sqft 1,876 Sqft
A4583445 Listing No. A4583445
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(41)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(53)
$3,997,000
2 2 Beds
2 2 Baths
954 Sqft 954 Sqft
N6119928 Listing No. N6119928
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(53)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(98)
$3,995,000
4 4 Beds
4 4 Baths
3,273 Sqft 3,273 Sqft
A4648103 Listing No. A4648103
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(98)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(91)
$3,950,000
4 4 Beds
4 | 2 4 | 2 Baths
3,582 Sqft 3,582 Sqft
A4648844 Listing No. A4648844
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(91)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(45)
$3,850,000
2 2 Beds
2 2 Baths
1,940 Sqft 1,940 Sqft
N6137556 Listing No. N6137556
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(45)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(96)
$3,675,000
4 4 Beds
3 | 1 3 | 1 Baths
2,380 Sqft 2,380 Sqft
N6134765 Listing No. N6134765
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(96)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(61)
$3,499,000
5 5 Beds
3 | 1 3 | 1 Baths
3,700 Sqft 3,700 Sqft
A4636300 Listing No. A4636300
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(61)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(57)
$2,950,000
3 3 Beds
2 2 Baths
1,729 Sqft 1,729 Sqft
A4634966 Listing No. A4634966
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(57)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(91)
$2,597,700
4 4 Beds
4 | 1 4 | 1 Baths
4,347 Sqft 4,347 Sqft
N6134950 Listing No. N6134950
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(91)
VIRTUAL TOUR
(83)
$2,345,000
3 3 Beds
3 | 1 3 | 1 Baths
2,473 Sqft 2,473 Sqft
A4638465 Listing No. A4638465
House Property Type: House
VIRTUAL TOUR
(83)
The data relating to real estate displayed on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) Program of Stellar MLS. All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; the availability of any listing should always be independently verified. Listing information is provided for consumers' personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.